A certificate of insurance is not the policy: what a COI shows, and what it doesn't

Most companies treat a subcontractor's COI as proof of coverage and file it. The certificate itself says otherwise in its small print. This article explains what a COI actually tells you, where the gaps are and the few steps that close the ones that matter.

What a COI is

A certificate of insurance is a one-page summary of the insurance a company holds, usually prepared by its insurance agent or broker. For liability coverage it is typically the standard ACORD 25 form. It lists the insured, the insurers, the policy numbers, the policy period, the limits and the certificate holder.

The form carries a disclaimer to this effect: the certificate is issued as a matter of information only, confers no rights on the certificate holder, and does not amend, extend or alter the coverage of the policies listed. That wording matters, because it means the certificate describes the policy and is not the policy.

A COI is still the right first document to collect. It is quick, standard and easy to compare against a requirement. The risk is treating it as the last one.

What a COI shows, and what it can miss

Use the right-hand column as a list of questions to ask when the risk justifies it.

Looks fine on the certificateWhat it may still hide
Policy period covers the jobThe policy may have been cancelled after the certificate was issued. The certificate does not update itself.
Limits meet the contractSublimits, exclusions or erosion of aggregate limits by other claims are not visible.
Additional insured box tickedAdditional insured status is granted by endorsement. The box shows intent, and the endorsement shows what is actually covered.
Waiver of subrogation notedIt needs an endorsement on the policy to take effect, and some policies only grant it where a written contract requires it.
Right company nameA parent, a former name or a related entity may be insured while the entity on your contract is not.
Notice of cancellation languageThe certificate does not guarantee you will receive notice. Only the policy provisions and endorsements do.
Trade listed as coveredThe operations actually performed may fall under an exclusion or a classification that does not match.

General information, not legal advice. Your contract, state law and your insurer or broker decide what is required and what is enough.

How to close the gap before a subcontractor starts

You do not need to read every policy. Match the effort to the risk of the work.

  1. Set the requirement first. Decide the coverage types, limits and endorsements by risk tier before the certificate arrives, so you have something to compare it with.
  2. Check the basics on every certificate. Named insured, policy period, limits, certificate holder and description of operations. Reject anything that does not match the contract.
  3. Ask for endorsements where they carry weight. For higher-risk work, ask for the additional insured and waiver endorsements, and have your broker review them.
  4. Confirm directly on significant jobs. Contact the issuing agent or broker to confirm the policy is in force, especially for larger exposures.
  5. Track the expiry and ask for the renewal early. Open a renewal well before the policy ends. A lapse found at the next billing cycle is a lapse that went uninsured.

Where this fits in your process

A certificate is one part of the file. The full process of setting insurance requirements is covered in the subcontractor insurance requirements checklist, and the routine of tracking certificates as they expire is in the guide to contractor insurance certificate tracking. For the wider set of documents US teams collect, see contractor compliance tracking in the US.

AuditSci stores the certificate against the requirement, proposes the policy period and named insured from the document, and lets your reviewer confirm them before it counts. It tracks the expiry and opens the renewal. It does not contact insurers or confirm that a policy is in force.

Frequently asked questions

Does a certificate of insurance prove a subcontractor is covered?

It shows the coverage as of the date it was issued. It is not the policy, it does not amend or extend the coverage, and it does not update if the policy later changes or is cancelled. For significant risks, confirm with the agent or broker and ask for the key endorsements.

Who issues a COI?

The insured's insurance agent or broker, usually on request. It is normally free and quick to obtain, which is why you can ask for a fresh certificate at renewal.

How long is a certificate valid?

A COI has no validity of its own. It is useful until the earliest policy expiry date listed on it. Most liability policies run for twelve months, so track each expiry date and ask for the renewal early.

What is the certificate holder?

The party the certificate is issued to, often you or your client. Being the certificate holder does not give you rights under the policy. Additional insured status does that, through an endorsement.

Should I accept a certificate showing an expired policy?

No, not as proof of current coverage. Ask for a current certificate, or for evidence that the policy was renewed, before the subcontractor works.

Does AuditSci verify policies with insurers?

No. AuditSci stores the certificate, proposes the dates and named insured, and lets a reviewer confirm them. It tracks the expiry and opens the renewal. It does not contact insurers.